| Campaign objective and audience fit | 15% | State the campaign goal, recipient group, distribution setting, and intended action or impression. | Can the supplier recommend products suited to the audience, occasion, and intended use? | A product shortlist that explains the purpose and audience fit of each option. |
| Practicality and expected use | 10% | Specify how recipients are likely to use or carry the item, and any size, material, or care requirements. | Are product dimensions, materials, care instructions, and intended use clearly documented? | Product specifications, images, and a physical sample when the item’s feel or function matters. |
| Total budget and price transparency | 12% | Set a total project budget and target quantity. Include product, decoration, setup, shipping, taxes, and any other applicable charges. | Does the written quote itemize costs and show how pricing changes with quantity, decoration, or shipping? | An itemized quote with currency, quote validity, assumptions, and any additional fees stated. |
| Product quality and durability | 12% | Define acceptable material, construction, finish, and performance for the product’s intended use. | Can the supplier provide specifications, samples, or inspection details relevant to the product? | Sample review, written specifications, and a clear process for reporting defects or order discrepancies. |
| Customization and artwork | 8% | Prepare artwork, placement preferences, colors, and any requirements for legibility or decoration method. | What file formats, decoration methods, proofing steps, and revision limits apply? | A digital proof approved before production, with artwork placement and colors clearly shown. |
| Production and delivery schedule | 12% | Set the in-hands date, delivery destination, and time needed for approval, production, and transit. | Is the proposed schedule confirmed in writing, including proof approval deadlines and shipping assumptions? | A written timeline with milestones, estimated dispatch date, delivery method, and contingency options. |
| Order quantity and flexibility | 6% | Estimate the quantity needed, including any allowance for replacements, late additions, or multiple events. | What are the minimum order quantity, quantity increments, overage or shortage terms, and reorder options? | Written quantity terms and a quote for the planned amount, plus any likely alternate quantities. |
| Safety and regulatory requirements | 10% | Identify the destination market, recipient age group, and any product-specific safety or labeling needs. | What safety documentation or testing applies to this specific product and market? For U.S. children’s products, ask about applicable Children’s Product Certificate and testing requirements; do not assume these apply to every item. | Relevant, current documentation tied to the exact product and intended market; verify requirements for the product category. |
| Environmental and material claims | 5% | Define which material, packaging, or sourcing attributes matter to the campaign. | Can each environmental claim be substantiated with product-specific details or documentation? | Specific material and packaging information; avoid relying on broad, unsupported terms such as “eco-friendly.” |
| Communication and issue resolution | 5% | Decide who will approve proofs, receive updates, and handle questions or delivery issues. | Who is the project contact, how are updates provided, and what is the process for addressing problems? | Clear points of contact, documented response expectations, and a defined resolution process. |
| Packaging and distribution logistics | 5% | Specify individual packaging, kitting, labeling, split shipments, or delivery to multiple locations if needed. | Can the supplier meet the packing and shipping plan, and are these services and costs included in the quote? | Written packing instructions, shipping destinations, quantities per location, and cost breakdown. |